What's new in the DCU?
Batgirl Adventures #1
by Paul Dini and Rick Burchett, published by DC, color, $2.95
Rating: Neat-O.
Excellent story in the "adventures" style, written by one of the best authors of the Batman Adventures cartoon, and featuring some of my favorite characters from the cartoon. Harley Quinn, some-time sidekick to the Joker, stirs up trouble in order to get one of the Bat-clan after her, so that she can lead them to where her pal Poison Ivy is in desperate trouble; Batgirl is the one she happens across first. For someone like me, who's always resented what Alan Moore did to Barbara Gordon/Batgirl in The Killing Joke, much less the fact that they decided to keep it in continuity, this comic is the ticket. (It's sexism, is what it is. Batman can come back from a broken back, Superman can come back from the dead, but BatGIRL isn't important--she's just a dame. Actually, I think the real reason is that nobody wants to get rid of the wheelchair-bound Barbara Gordon/Oracle created by John Ostrander in Suicide Squad--she's too good a character. Sigh. Sometimes I think there's nothing half so dangerous to your favorite characters as a good writer; nobody has any problem agreeing to ignore what was done to Adam Strange or Zatanna. But I digress.)
DCU Holiday Bash II
by various, published by DC, color, $3.95
Rating: varies.
I bought this for the Tony Isabella/Eddie Newell 'Twas the Night Before Kwanzaa, and fortunately it was almost worth the full $3.95 price all by its lonesome, because the rest of the comic (except for the silly Present Tense, which neatly lampoons Darkseid, the second most overused villain in the DCU), wasn't worth the paper it was printed on. The stories ranged from the trite The Gift, to the incoherent The House of Peace.
Gog #1
by Mark Waid, Jerry Ordway, and Dennis Janke, published by DC, color, $1.95
rating: Keen.
I have to admit, I haven't been looking forward to The Kingdom, the upcoming maybe-prequel to Kingdom Come. Mostly its because I look at Kingdom Come as a kind of cautionary tale, a polemic against the kind of "Image-age" version of heroism where a hero is nothing but a name, a costume, and a set of powers, and the "kewlest" one is the one who racks up the highest body-count; if The Kingdom is going to lead the DCU (already perilously close to that sort of thing with the existence of Lobo in the main continuity) further in that direction, even for the sake of a good story (and Kingdom Come was a great story), then that makes me nervous. The industry is littered with the wreckage of once-good comics that were ruined by not-so-great writers trying to imitate the big stories of the great writers (The Dark Knight Returns, and Watchmen come to mind) but coming away with only the surface effects (the whole "grim'n'gritty" phenomenon), and I frankly worry that The Kingdom is going to lead to more of the same, but worse. I mean, the future depicted at the start of Kingdom Come, even before the Kansas incident, was bad--it was not a future that I want to read stories about.
So what does this have to do with Gog? Well, Gog is the prequel to the prequel--it's a lead-up to The Kingdom, introducing the villain Gog, who presumably (by name, costume, and powers, the hallmark of the Image-age character) will result in Magog, of Kingdom Come. It's a good story, with a fairly interesting origin for the villain (what the hell was the Phantom Stranger thinking? I mean, it's clear that the other "Elders" of the DCU have some hidden agenda, but he should have realized that they had something up their sleeves. Oh, well.), but I worry. I worry.
JLA: Year One #2
by Mark Waid, Brian Augustyn, and Barry Kitson, published by DC, color, $1.95
Rating: Neat-O.
I like this book a whole bunch, but I still can't shake the feeling when I'm reading it that this is not the Justice League of America. Sorry Mark, sorry Brian, I know that the mess that is current DCU continuity is not your fault, but the JLA was founded with Wonder Woman, not Black Canary, and Superman was a member. I have the comics that say so. (Actually, I have the Archives, but it's the same thing.) It's a great Elseworlds, but it doesn't hit me like the real thing. I think I'm officially adopting Craig Schutt's explanation that everything in the DCU since Crisis has taken place on Earth-Crisis, and then on Earth-Zero after Zero-Hour. As JLA (Earth-Zero): Year One, this is a bang-up job.